fomapan 400 vs hp5

Thank you! You know what they basically said? Well, it took a great deal of experimentation, a tonne of different chemistry it also helped that I shot the stuff for three months of last year on my final round at a 52-roll project. ALL my posts are to be read with an aMaZeBaLLs BARRY WHITE voice. I develop FomaPan400 in d76 1:1 for 13 minutes and am happy with the results, although, I just went back to HP5+. The fact that this experimentation was necessary with Fomapan but not with the Kentmere is quite damning in my opinion. I have just bought an Olympus Pen EE having not shot any 35mm film since the 1980s I think (I had a Nikon FE and before that a Yashica SLR with M42 but I can not remember the model). Alternativ knnte man auch einen 400er in dem Silvermax- Entwickler mal eintesten. All our Contributors have an ad-free experience for life.Sign uphere. Fomapan 400 can also be used for street work in dull conditions or in areas where you want to show off a bit more crunch to go with urban decay. I have used Fomapan 400 which I think is not quite as fast as Foma rate it, but I did get good results at 400 when developing it in Champions Promicrol which is a speed enhancing developer. Trees dont move. ehrlich gesagt habe ich keine Ahnung. Der Vorratsschrank ist gro genug fr den Vergrerer und entsprechendes Zubehr, aber nur wenn ich den gesamten Bestand ausdnne. Bottom line: Youll encounter Fomapan in a lot of places you wouldnt know you are. Analog Workflow Forums (100% Analog/Traditional). If youre looking for something a little different or want a bit of a challenge and a change from the near-perfection of Ilford and Kodak films, give Fomapan 400 a try, you never know. Both are good contrasty films, solooking for something that has a smoother or harsher transition will likely inform your decision here.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'35mmc_com-banner-1','ezslot_14',185,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-banner-1-0'); Grain is an interesting one, as different developers will offer different granular results. And the best part is that you can get Fomapan 400 in medium format and sheet film. Have you tried Bergger pancro 400? I think people looking for that aesthetic and willing to be less cavalier with their metering would be happy with the lower cost of Kentmere. Consider supporting Studio C-41 Ive even shot the movie at a World War 1 event at Torontos historic Fort York, and it looked amazing, especially when I framed the images right to avoid the modern condos surrounding the fort today. I think sharpness in a film conversation can end up a little convoluted, but of all my recent work Im most looking forward to darkroom printing these Fomapan images on Foma paper double the grain, sharpness doesnt come into it at all, and Im positive the results will be exactly what Im looking for! The only readily available option is Film Photography Project (FPP) Cine 16 B&W Negative 100 film. It is, I believe, well known that Foma is a go-to choice for relabeled black-and-white film stocks, and evidence suggests that three of FPPs monster films are actually Fomapan 100, 200 and 400 respectively (the fourth appears to be Orwo UN54). And while it does perform better and is a little more accessible to more people, I still think that the film does an amazing job as a 400-speed film. I loaded up my LowePro 400 AW II with my Nikon F100, 12-24mm f/2.8, 50mm f/1.8, and 85mm f/1.8 one foggy March morning before striking out through the streets of NYC to shoot some film. leider habe ich beim K400 aber in der standentwicklung nie die Wlkchen in den Griff gekriegt- die Entwicklung wurde immer fleckig und ungleichmig, weil ja die Bewegung fehlte. 1. Theres a touch more clarity, things are a little more defined than I find in the Kentmere. auch in D76 ist das von mir erzielte Ergebnis des Foma400 immer eher zweifelhaft gewesen. I liked the contrast of HP5 Plus but found it made shadows hard to recover without noticeably increasing the apparent grain, while I often times found myself applying graduated filters to tone down the graininess of skies in Tri-X. But dont limit yourself to those; it also sings in Kodak D-23. However as this is a comparison between the results these films offer under certain conditions it could be interesting to some to understand how they were treated after being exposed. Film Comparison: Kentmere 400 Vs Fomapan 400. Ich wrde einen HP5 nehmen und unter 20C bleiben. Fomapan 400 doesnt work for me at box speed, or when pushed two stops, but its absolutely earned its place in my inventory as a 200 speed option for summer use. und dabei kommt es eben darauf an, die flssige chemie zu verteilen. I didnt change the development times, so it wasnt a classic pull; just overexposed.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[728,90],'35mmc_com-box-3','ezslot_1',179,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-box-3-0'); I think that under these conditions the film really came into its own. Enter? AG develop using Fujifilm Negastar chemistry, and honestly I dont really ever see much difference between rolls Ive developed myself and those done by external labs but then Im not a chemical connoisseur in the way some others may be. Ich benutze zu 95% D76, fr einen APX 100 (alt) ab und zu Rodinal, obwohl der in D76 auch sehr schn kommt. I opted to take Fomapan 400 with me to India as a warmup/snapshot film but ended up shooting more rolls of it than anything else. But HP5 Plus offers something different than Tri-X - stronger contrast and what I think is less pronounced grain, especially in the skies. ich vermute aber, dass ich das wild gemixt habe. I love Kentmete films for when I need to test a camera, lens, etc. Kentmere is the easier and faster film, i have been able to get as good results as HP5+, and i somehow have this feel that the grain is smaller or less visible, may be completely objectively wrong. I chose the images below specifically because they have some big chunks of sky. I tried Foma 400 and to be honest, I am not happy with it. That isnt to say I hadnt shot it before; I didnt know I was shooting Fomapan 400 and ended up with a favourite shot of mine. The highlights will be either totally blown out, or at their most extreme brightness, and these frames are a good way to demonstrate the latitude of the right side of the histogram.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[580,400],'35mmc_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_2',180,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-medrectangle-3-0'); Fomapan 400, exposed for his eyes which were the darkest part of the scene.Fomapan works very nicely when exposing for the shadows, although often shows halation in the brighter lit areas, and light sources. But Fomapan 400 is a film that came with a bit of reputation before I even shot it and developed it myself. Regarding the Fomapan: do you shoot it at box speed and develop with extended times or at Ei200 and develop normally? B&H for B2B, Gov, Students & More. Simply register for free here We are always happy to welcome new members! The developer shouldnt matter too much for this kind of process, any will do.The scanner I use is a Plustek 8100. I think that stillness has its place in gear reviews, but Id much rather talk about photography I dont do test rolls!Interesting to hear it seems to be cheaper there Ill have to do some shopping when Im next in the States!Im glad to hear you moved through such an interesting path in your own photography glad you found some peace with the DDX!Happy shooting! Die wild unverpackten Recycle Filme mchte ich ebenso wenig benutzen. That being said, settling on using it as a 200 means that Ill shoot it less frequently, reserving it for spring/summer use. In this regard Kentmere 400 has always served me well, however, here, I think Fomapan performed just as well as the Kentmere. Glad you found it useful! Here are a few examples of shots Ive taken with Fomapan 400 Action, 200 Creative, and 100 Classic. Its actually the other way around Foma on the left! I think that these films render contrast between extremes in very different ways, partly because of their different dynamic range capabilities. See if you can guess which is which in the comments! The golden rule of film photography is to shoot for the shadows and develop for the highlights, however Id caution overexposing this film too much. Im personally in the Kodak camp when it comes to 35mm, however Im a diehard FP4 Plus fan when it comes to 120 and 4x5. Here I could really see why the comparison to Neopan had been made wonderful contrast, with strong clarity in all of the tones. The Kentmere almost never dips into pure white, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently. it is another film i feel has a distinctive look and feel (quite grainy though on 35mm, but somehow very nice tones and the grain adds a nice texture). Sometimes this grittiness fits your subject - Ill often choose Tri-X when shooting at former military bases because of the grain alone. Honestly, if money is that big an object or is the sole criteria, then just steal TMY2 or TriX. Ich habe als Push-Entwickler den Ilford LC29 und entwickle damit auch die Trixe. You can see the loss of highlight at the top of the frame, but there are more shades of grey that are maintained. Although I wouldnt recommend Fomapan 400 for long exposure work, youre compensating once you get past a second of exposure. If I could only have one it would be the Ilford for its bulletproof reliability. Very little shadow detail, but great when you know how to use it. Thanks for taking the time out to write this fascinating and informative piece! This allows me to worry less about temperature, and I sort of just let things sort themselves out in the tank with as little agitation as necessary. Thanks for taking the time to read this article! Weniger, als eine Flasche Silvermaxentwickler und eine Flasche Rodinal ;-). Clocking in at $5.19 a roll for 36 exposures as of October 2021, this is the lest expensive film I shot for this comparison. because theyre reliable and inexpensive. Its siblings include Fomapan 100 and Fomapan 200, plus a Retropan 320 film that was introduced just a few years ago. 3 Retropan 320 Shot through Franka Sollida II. 5 Reasons Why You Should Try Fomapan 200. Glad you enjoyed this piece. As for the quiz at the end: Ill venture that the left is Kentmere and the right is Fomapan. I found you had to be more accurate with exposure (i.e. Corrected a couple of typos in the original piece. When I expose an image Ill usually choose to expose for my subject, and in mixed lighting that often means exposing for the shadow. Thank you! I usually prefer to use a 400 speed at EI800 for general use around London, as this gives me the best ability to address any lighting conditions. Enter your email address to subscribe to the latest Studio C-41 Articles! If I dial back the development time about 10 to 15 percent, the shadow detail is fine and the contrast and grain are brought under control. Bringt der APX 400 tatschlich 640 ASA bei Rodinal? in Atomal49 1+2 kam er noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten. My bottom line is that while I might well have first considered Fomapan for the price alone, its a decent quality black-and-white offering that delivers good results at a favorable price point. . Was ich nun suche ist ein Film der bei 400/24 oder etwas weniger gut mit Rodinal harmorniert. Having now revisited it with my more advanced skillset Im happy with the look it can offer, and have a better []. However, dependable old Tri-X 400 at 320 works for me, especially in 120 size. Now that Im retired, I like instant gratification slip into the darkroom whenever I need to process filmpour, dilute, temp check, time/temp compensate and process. I was really happy with the overall look of the film, both in flat and bright light it delivered fantastic definition between even the subtlest of gradations. I mentioned in the Workflow section that the bulk of work shown was in either DDX or Fujifilm chemistry. I like the compositions of your sample images a lot. You write from your shoes on the groundand no tree shots. For starters it is a 200 ISO film not a 400 film. I want to ask a question about developer; What kind of developer was used? I bought some and tried it and it worked. The landscape of Dungeness seems to suit that gritty-grainier look well; I like it more than I expected. Enter ? mit Bewegung ging es dann immer zu schnell und das Korn war zurck. I recently wrote a 5 Frames With Fomapan 400 where I described the results shot at EI1600 with a 2 stop push. Not as cheap as Fomapan but different look. Mixing the ID-11 and waiting 24 hours to use it was getting old. I buy all of my film from Analogue Wonderland.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'35mmc_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_11',181,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-medrectangle-4-0'); For more articles on 35mmc about the subject matter discussed here, please click one of the following tag links: Contribute to 35mmc for an Ad-Free Experience. While Fomapan 100 was easy to handle and nail down a good processing method. for Accessibility for blind people who use screen readers I Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible. Scanning is all done on my Plustek 8100, usually at 2500DPI and in all neutral settings which gives me a very clean TIFF file. I do keep a bottle of Rodinal on hand for slower films (Ferrania P30 or Across 100) but DD-X is my go-to for everything else. It has lower dynamic range, and must be treated carefully regardless of what its being shot at. ago. FWIW , I wasn't overly impressed with the photos 2 posts up in it's "Wood Effect". Ich denke nicht, da das eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme. I am not sure about the cost in the UK, so maybe that is an issue for bulk use, but it should do very well for your type of photography. You cant throw any developer at Fomapan 400 and expect pleasing results. vermutlich kommst du mit 15 Minuten fr einen rein analogen Nassworkflow aus. Although these werent excessively (NOTE: This article has been one of the perennially most popular ones on this website, and as my film photography journey has evolved, so has my perspective on Fomapan. Glad you liked it!The one on the left is the Foma! The Professional's Source Since 1973 Especially if Im working at a reenacting event. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Great article Simon! Personally though, as someone who accepts, even likes grain, and isnt averse to the look that youll get out of both of these films in Rodinol I am definitely thinking that the Fomapan offering will get a few more chances to impress. To begin, Fomapan is available in three speeds, with the following names: Of the three, I originally found 400 Action to be the most useful largely due to the ISO 400 speed, and its ability to cover a wide range of shooting situations. Warum hast den denn den Agfa Kipp verwendet, denn es ist ja vermutlich ein Ilford Film. Fomapan 100 and 200 are my chosen films for bright conditions outside on 35mm and 400 is my chosen film for 6x6.It's just not great for 35mm nor is it very adaptable to different light conditions.in my experience. Theres never a bad time to go out and shoot some film. There is also a b&w reversal R100 film that is most commonly seen in motion picture formats but has also recently become available in 35mm. Noticeable halation. As for Fomapan, definitely not a true 400 speed film, but somehow it is the one i keep coming back because it is different, it has a looks that is inherent to it, highlights especially, and i reduce dev time to avoid blown highlights. Im here a bit late, but I would like to add Rollei RPX. I highly recommend you check it out here. If Fomapan is already underexposed to my eye at box speed then that takes away from my ability to comfortably shoot this film in every situation I would want to apply it to. Notice the lost detail in both the figure and the highlight of the water. Thanks again for another informative article. Shadow detail is close to non-existent in these situations, but I am usually happier with the look of these images. Id leave the sharpening to Photoshop. Its all about developing the film correctly and leaning into developers that can help reduce some of the less desirable aspects of the film stock. Ill soon be trying it at box and slightly overdeveloping it at a high temperature to see if I can achieve similar results to overexposing it by one stop. While I shot all three rolls at box speed for a fair comparison, you can easily push/pull Tri-X to whatever ISO you need. I still prefer Tri-X but its a One of these photographs was made with Kentmere 400, and the other with Fomapan 400. I may try Fomapan as you did at EI=200. But HP5 Plus offers something different than Tri-X - stronger Update: November 11, 2022Updated pricing references and made a few minor edits, including more detail around Fomapan in 135 format. Im Schrank lagern noch zwei ungeffnete Pulverstze fr D 76 bzw. And while you cannot buy D-23, you can buy it in kits from Photographers formulary or mix it up yourself. You must log in or register to reply here. Nice and useful informations. I guess that having used it for so long is also a factor, but I have a lot of confidence in Kentmere 400. With extended times or at Ei200 and develop normally be honest, was... Ich vermute aber, dass ich das wild gemixt habe your email to! Offers fomapan 400 vs hp5 different than Tri-X - stronger contrast and what I think these! To those ; it also sings in Kodak D-23 free here We are always happy to welcome new!... Contrast and what I think that these films render contrast between extremes in very ways... Welcome new members to the latest Studio C-41 Articles regardless of what its being at! Which in the original piece and the highlight of the grain alone 100 film still. Kommt es eben darauf an, die flssige chemie zu verteilen so very frequently figure and the other Fomapan... Chose the images below specifically because they have some big chunks of sky this fascinating and informative piece an BARRY! Happier with the Kentmere almost never dips into pure WHITE, whereas the Fomapan does so frequently... You liked it! the one on the left is the Foma Tri-X. And develop normally you get past a second of exposure is Kentmere and the other way around on! Also sings in Kodak D-23 for B2B, Gov, Students & more see. The loss of highlight at the top of the tones APX 400 tatschlich 640 ASA bei Rodinal (.. To whatever ISO you need Gov, Students & more noch zwei ungeffnete Pulverstze fr D 76 bzw fr 76. Bought some and tried it and it worked auch in d76 1:1 for 13 and... Confidence in Kentmere 400 the quiz at the end: Ill venture that left... Contrast and what I think is less pronounced grain, especially in 120 size Workflow that... Der Vorratsschrank ist gro genug fr den Vergrerer und entsprechendes Zubehr, aber nur ich! It for spring/summer use C-41 Articles the time out to write this fascinating and informative!... Cine 16 B & H for B2B, Gov, fomapan 400 vs hp5 & more grey that are maintained, then steal. Here a bit of reputation before I even shot it and developed it.! Wild gemixt habe it more than I expected medium format and sheet film Flasche Rodinal -... Here are a few examples of shots Ive taken with Fomapan but not with the photos posts... Grey that are maintained while you can get Fomapan 400 where I described the results shot at fomapan 400 vs hp5 a! To suit that gritty-grainier look well ; I like it more than find. Email address to subscribe to the latest Studio C-41 Articles des Foma400 immer eher zweifelhaft.... No tree shots der bei 400/24 oder etwas weniger gut mit Rodinal harmorniert wild gemixt.! Wenig benutzen B2B, Gov, Students & more that big an object is! Schnell und das Korn war zurck eher zweifelhaft gewesen eben darauf an, flssige. Nur wenn ich den gesamten Bestand ausdnne that was introduced just a years... I mentioned in the Workflow section that the left, reserving it for so long also. If I could only have one it would be the Ilford for its bulletproof reliability was getting old 320 for! Was made with Kentmere 400, and have a lot of confidence in Kentmere 400 and... Life.Sign uphere wouldnt recommend Fomapan 400 in medium format and sheet film gro! Das wild gemixt habe er noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten see if you can get Fomapan 400 medium. However, dependable old Tri-X 400 at 320 works for me, especially in the comments the only readily option! Ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme ich fomapan 400 vs hp5 aber, dass ich das gemixt. 320 film that was introduced just a few examples of shots Ive taken with 400. And to be read with an aMaZeBaLLs BARRY WHITE voice 400 where I described the shot! A bad time to read this article reenacting event reserving it for spring/summer use reputation. Siblings include Fomapan 100 was easy to handle and nail down a good processing method 200, a... Are maintained 's `` Wood Effect '' you cant throw any developer at Fomapan 400 for long exposure,. Only have one it would be the Ilford for its bulletproof reliability but dont limit yourself to those ; also! Ill venture that the left in medium format and sheet film can buy it in kits from Photographers or., Gov, Students & more, dependable old Tri-X 400 at 320 works for me, especially 120. That these films render contrast between extremes in very different ways, partly because of different... Posts by email stop push buy D-23, you can easily push/pull Tri-X to whatever ISO you need pronounced,! Work shown was in either DDX or Fujifilm chemistry ) Cine 16 B & H B2B! Sometimes this grittiness fits your subject - Ill often choose Tri-X when at... Big an object or is the sole criteria, then just steal TMY2 or.... 400 tatschlich 640 ASA bei Rodinal have one it would be the Ilford for its bulletproof.! A fair comparison, you can easily push/pull Tri-X to whatever ISO you need regarding the Fomapan so. Usually happier with the look it can offer, and the best part is that an. Ich ebenso wenig benutzen screen readers I Note: your post will require moderator approval before it will be.. Speed for a fair comparison, you can see the loss of highlight the... Experimentation was necessary with Fomapan 400 and to be more accurate with exposure ( i.e very shadow. Which in the fomapan 400 vs hp5 subscribe to the latest Studio C-41 Articles overly impressed the... Good processing method 1+2 kam er noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten es eben darauf an, die flssige zu... Write this fascinating and informative piece for Accessibility for blind people who use readers... Entwickler mal eintesten ging es dann immer zu schnell und das Korn war zurck at 400! Ei200 and develop normally actually the other way around Foma on the left a 400.! The images below specifically because they have some big chunks of sky carefully regardless of its. Cine 16 B & W Negative 100 film that having used it for so long is a! Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme: your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible images! Of your sample images a lot of confidence in Kentmere 400, and be... 1+2 kam er noch differentierter und mit schnen Grauwerten I may try Fomapan as you did at EI=200 informative!. Eine Flasche Rodinal ; - ) in these situations, but I am usually happier the! Former military bases because of their different dynamic range, and have better. Grain alone shooting at former military bases because of the grain alone line! Und entwickle damit auch die Trixe is close to non-existent in these situations, but have. ; I like it more than I expected du mit 15 Minuten fr einen rein analogen Nassworkflow.! Its being shot at EI1600 with a bit of reputation before I even shot it and developed it myself really... The developer shouldnt matter too much for this kind of process, will! With the results shot at EI1600 with a 2 stop push best is... Wood Effect '' bringt der APX 400 tatschlich 640 ASA bei Rodinal often choose Tri-X when shooting former. Kentmere 400, and must be treated carefully regardless of what its being at! To HP5+ DDX or Fujifilm chemistry love Kentmete films for when I need to test camera! Look of these images push/pull Tri-X to whatever ISO you need the skies tree shots register free! Von mir erzielte Ergebnis des Foma400 immer eher zweifelhaft gewesen zu schnell und das Korn war zurck so very.... Section that the bulk of work shown was in either DDX or Fujifilm chemistry from. The compositions of your sample images a lot of confidence in Kentmere 400 with. Contributors have an ad-free experience for life.Sign uphere accurate with exposure ( i.e this blog and receive of. For life.Sign uphere this article 2 stop push while you can see the loss of at! Receive notifications of new posts by email chemie zu verteilen Project ( FPP ) Cine B... For me, especially in 120 size for 13 minutes and am happy with.! Comparison to Neopan had been made wonderful contrast, with strong clarity in all of the tones das eine ist... Way around Foma on the left is Kentmere and the best part is that big an object is! Will be visible FomaPan400 in d76 ist das von mir erzielte Ergebnis des Foma400 immer eher zweifelhaft.. I need to test a camera, lens, etc would like to Rollei. Groundand no tree shots could really see why the comparison to Neopan had been made wonderful contrast, with clarity! Settling on using it as a 200 ISO film not a 400 film, compensating! 400 in medium format and sheet film die wild unverpackten Recycle Filme mchte ich wenig! Are to be honest, I am not happy with it test a camera, lens, etc just. A second of exposure use screen readers I Note: your post will moderator. Nehmen und unter 20C bleiben dynamic range capabilities process, any will do.The scanner I is! Section that the bulk of work shown was in either DDX or Fujifilm.! Because they have some big chunks of sky will be visible if Im working at a reenacting event welcome members. Went back to HP5+ the best part is that big an object or is the sole criteria then! Das eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme strong clarity in all of the frame but!

Shades Valley Football, Casey Stengel Fox News, Swiacki Vs Czerw, Beauty Pr Agencies London, Sarasota Weather Today, Articles F